Menu
Powder & Lead
  • Home
  • Rifle/Long Guns
  • Pistols
  • Cartridges
  • Black Powder
  • Reloading
  • Historical Figures
  • Historical Stories
  • About this site
  • Contact Us
  • Shop
  •  
Powder & Lead

Colt 1851 Navy vs 1860 Army: A Comparative Analysis

Affiliate Disclosure: Powder & Lead is reader-supported. When you buy through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission at no extra cost to you. This helps us keep producing honest, independent content. We only recommend products we genuinely believe in. Full disclosure.
1851 Navy vs 1860 Army: Colt Model 1851 Navy revolver serial no. 2, made in 1850, with its octagonal barrel
Colt Model 1851 Navy, serial no. 2, made in Hartford in 1850. The Metropolitan Museum of Art, 68.157.2, Gift of John E. Parsons, 1968. Public domain, via The Met Open Access.

In the 1851 Navy vs 1860 Army comparison, the two Colts share most of a frame and differ in caliber, cylinder and barrel. The Model 1851 Navy is a .36 caliber, six-shot percussion revolver with a 7 1/2-inch octagonal barrel, made in Hartford from 1850 to 1873. The Model 1860 Army fitted a .44 caliber cylinder to the same frame, added an 8-inch round barrel, and became the main revolver of Union troops in the Civil War. This comparison draws on Colt’s 1850 patent, the 1862 report of the War Department’s ordnance commission, the 1860 Army board’s conclusion as quoted in American Rifleman, and museum records of surviving guns. For the 1860 Army’s own story in more depth, see our history of the Colt 1860 Army.

1851 Navy vs 1860 Army at a Glance

Colt 1851 NavyColt 1860 Army
Caliber.36.44
Barrel7 1/2 in., octagonal8 in., round (some early guns 7 1/2 in.)
CylinderSix shots, straightSix shots, rebated (stepped down at the rear); early guns fluted
Loading leverLever rammer under the barrelCreeping lever with a ratchet
Weight2 lb 10 oz2 lb 11 oz
Made1850 to 1873, nearly a quarter million1860 to about 1873, about 200,500
Colt’s price when the Army appeared$20$25
Bought by the Union in the warAbout 35,000127,157 delivered by Colt, plus 1,000 with shoulder stocks and about 2,000 bought on the open market (McAulay); about 129,730 (Pate, via Rock Island)

The barrel, weight, production and purchase figures come from the Met, the Smithsonian, the National Firearms Museum, American Rifleman and Rock Island Auction Company, cited in the sections below and in the Sources list. The prices are Rock Island’s.

The 1851 Navy

Colt made the Navy in Hartford, where he set up his own factory after the Walker contract of 1847 (see our history of the Colt Walker). The Metropolitan Museum’s serial no. 2, shown above, is dated 1850. The Smithsonian’s record for its own Navy says that nearly a quarter million of the .36 caliber six-shot model “were produced between 1850 and 1873.” Rock Island Auction Company counts “more than 215,000 produced in the United States and 42,000 in London.”

Colt first sold it under other names. Rock Island writes that it was “Initially referred to the ‘Revolving Belt Pistol’ and the ‘Ranger Model’.” It sat between the .31 caliber pocket pistols and the .44 caliber Dragoon, a holster pistol carried on horseback (see our history of the Colt Third Model Dragoon). The Met gives its standard form as .36 caliber, with a 7 1/2-inch barrel and a six-shot cylinder, weighing “two pounds, ten ounces.”

The cylinder carries a roll-engraved naval battle designed by Waterman Lilly Ormsby, a bank-note engraver who had worked for Colt since at least 1839. The Met says the scene “depicts a battle between warships of the Republic of Texas and Mexico that occurred on May 16, 1843.” That was the second action off Campeche. The journal of Midshipman Alfred Walke, kept aboard ship in the Texas Navy squadron off Campeche and published by the Texas State Library, records “The Second Action May 16th 1843.” On one gold-inlaid Navy in the Met’s collection the scene is engraved by hand.

Both services bought it. Rock Island records that “The U.S. Navy purchased their first 100 Colt Navy revolvers in June 1852” and that “The U.S. Army accepted the Model 1851 Navy revolver in early 1855. Nearly 17,000 were delivered to the Ordnance Department over the next three years.” Revolvers made for the Navy Department had iron backstraps and trigger guards. Those bought by the Army had the standard brass ones.

Frederick Law Olmsted rode across Texas with Colt’s Navy revolvers and wrote about them in A Journey Through Texas, published in 1857. “Of the Colt’s we cannot speak in too high terms,” he wrote. “There are probably in Texas about as many revolvers as male adults, and I doubt if there are one hundred in the state of any other make.”

Colt also built Navies in London. The National Maritime Museum in Greenwich holds serial 23774, dated 1855, its barrel marked “ADDRESS COL COLT LONDON.” The museum’s record says thousands were produced for British forces in the Crimean War.

The 1860 Army

By the late 1850s the Dragoon’s weight had become a problem. John McAulay, writing in American Rifleman, says the weight of the Dragoon “was found to be a major detriment to its suitability for continued military service.” Colt’s answer kept the Navy’s frame and put a larger cylinder in it. In McAulay’s words, the new gun “incorporated the Model 1851 Navy’s frame, but accepted a .44-cal. rebated cylinder” and “a creeping, ratchet-type loading lever.”

A rebated cylinder is stepped. The front, which holds the six .44 caliber chambers, is larger in diameter than the rear, which is turned down to fit the Navy-sized frame. The step shows clearly on the Met’s serial 7569 below. The creeping lever works the rammer through a ratchet. Uberti, which builds the reproduction, describes it as “a geared rack and pinion system.”

Colt Model 1860 Army revolver serial no. 7569, made in 1861, showing the round barrel and rebated cylinder
Colt Model 1860 Army, serial no. 7569, made in Hartford in 1861. Samuel Colt presented it to Major Charles T. Baker of the 5th Connecticut Volunteers. The Metropolitan Museum of Art, 1983.442a (revolver), Gift of Mr. and Mrs. Jerry D. Berger, 1983. Public domain, via The Met Open Access.

In May 1860 Colt asked the War Department to test the new revolver, and a board of officers at the Washington Arsenal tested two of them, one with a 7 1/2-inch barrel and one with an 8-inch barrel, against a Third Model Dragoon for accuracy and penetration. McAulay quotes the board’s conclusion: “the board are satisfied that the new model revolver with the eight inch barrel will make the most superior cavalry arm we have ever had and they recommended the adoption of the new model and its issue to all mounted troops.”

Early guns had fluted cylinders. McAulay says these are found on “about 4,000 revolvers with serial numbers below 8000,” with the patent date stamped in one of the flutes. Rock Island gives “about 4,000 to 6,300.” After that the rebated round cylinder became standard. It carried the same naval battle scene as the Navy and six safety pins at the rear. The National Firearms Museum gives production as “About 200,500 Model 1860 Revolvers were made from 1860 through c. 1873.”

The two guns weigh almost the same. McAulay gives the Army as “2-pound, 11-ounce,” one ounce more than the Met’s figure for the Navy. Rock Island says the Army’s grip frame “was a quarter inch longer than the 1851 Navy.”

Colt’s 1850 Patent

The date stamped on the fluted Army cylinders is September 10, 1850. That is the date of Samuel Colt’s U.S. Patent No. 7,629, “Improvement in Revolving Chambered Fire-Arms,” which built on his patents of 1836 and 1839. The patent covers parts both revolvers use:

  • A bolt that locks the cylinder for each shot. Colt cut a shallow groove leading into each locking hole. The bolt drops into the groove as the cylinder turns and catches the next hole the moment the chamber lines up with the barrel. The patent says the arm “can be operated with the utmost rapidity without any danger of having the barrel out of its true line at the time of the discharge.”
  • A way to hold the cylinder “mid-way, or nearly so, between any two of the chambers” when the gun is at rest. The hammer fits onto a projection on the cylinder. On the 1860 Army those projections are the six safety pins McAulay describes at the rear of the cylinder.
  • Grooves cut around the cylinder pin to catch powder fouling, which “otherwise would take place after a few discharges.”
  • A barrel held on the front of the cylinder pin by a key, today called the wedge. The end of the pin bears against the bottom of its socket in the barrel, setting the gap between barrel and cylinder.

Both guns are open-top revolvers, with no strap over the cylinder, and the barrel is held on by the cylinder pin and the wedge. Uberti’s manual for its reproductions gives the takedown: tap the wedge out from the right side, use the loading lever against the cylinder to push the barrel off the pin, then lift out the cylinder.

.36 and .44 Compared

The difference in power comes from the size of the ball. Uberti’s instruction manual for its black powder revolvers gives round ball diameters of .375 or .380 inch for .36 caliber and .454 or .457 inch for .44 caliber. A pure lead ball of .375 inch weighs about 79 grains, and one of .454 inch about 140 grains. Those two figures are our arithmetic, from the Royal Society of Chemistry’s density for lead (11.3 grams per cubic centimeter) and the NIST definition of the grain (64.79891 milligrams).

McAulay writes that the 1860 board tested the new revolver against the Dragoon for accuracy and penetration, and he quotes only the board’s conclusion. The period records we read give no velocity for either revolver.

For reproductions, follow the maker’s manual; see the Reproductions section below.

In the Civil War

The Army model reached buyers just as the war began. McAulay records that “between December 1860 and April 1861, 2,230 Model 1860s were sent south,” and that the last 500 of them left the factory on April 15, 1861, for Peter Williams & Co. in Richmond. Our article on Colt’s sales to the South covers that trade.

The government paid Colt $25 a revolver at first. The primary record of that price is the report of the commission on ordnance contracts, dated July 1, 1862, and signed by J. Holt and Robert Dale Owen. It is printed in the Official Records, Series III, Volume 2. The commissioners wrote that “an order was given to Colt’s company for an indefinite number of his army revolvers at $25, and under this there has since been delivered 31,000.” When the War Department advertised for bids, Colt offered the same revolver at $14.50. The commissioners concluded that “in this single item of pistols alone there has been paid to that company within the time named at least $325,500 beyond the full value of the arms received.” The same report says E. Remington & Sons had offered its revolver in October 1861 at $15 but received an order for only 5,000.

McAulay totals the Army’s purchases: “Total factory deliveries came to 127,157. Two thousand more revolvers were purchased on the open market.” He adds that Colt “delivered to the Army an additional 1,000 1860 Colts with attachable shoulder stocks at $31 each on March 1, 1862.” The last delivery came on November 10, 1863. Rock Island, citing Charles Pate, gives “approximately 129,730” bought for the Union Army, “including 128,057 purchased from Colt directly or under contract.” Colt’s East Armory burned in early February 1864, and McAulay writes that afterwards “No further government orders for the Model 1860 were forthcoming” (see our article on the Colt factory fire of 1864).

The Navy model stayed in service alongside it. Rock Island says “More than 50 Union regiments were issued Colt 1851 Navy revolvers during the Civil War, with about 35,000 purchased by the Union military during the conflict.”

A return from the spring of 1865 shows what the Army of the Potomac’s cavalry carried. McAulay lists 8,354 revolvers: “4,260 .44-cal. Colts; 612 .36-cal. Colts; 257 .44-cal. Starrs; and 3,225 .44-cal. Remingtons.” In that return the .44 Colts outnumbered the .36 Colts by about seven to one, and Remingtons made up most of the rest. Read more on the arms of both sides in The Union Army Arsenal and Confederate Firearms.

The South copied the Navy. The Met’s Griswold and Gunnison revolver, serial 2651, was made at Griswoldville, Georgia, in 1864. The museum’s record says the factory produced “approximately 3,700 revolvers” and used enslaved labor. It built them with a brass frame and iron parts “instead of steel,” because raw materials were scarce.

After the War: Conversions and the Single Action Army

After the war many Navies and Armies were altered to fire metallic cartridges loaded from the rear. The Met has a Navy, serial 27060, made in 1853 and converted to the Thuer cartridge system about 1868 to 1871. On July 25, 1871, Charles B. Richards of Hartford, assignor to Colt, received U.S. Patent No. 117,461 for “Improvement in Revolving Fire-Arms.” Rock Island says that “Between 1871 and 1879, around 9,000 Model 1860 Army revolvers were converted to the Richards system.”

Colt ended production of both percussion models in about 1873, the year the Army adopted the Single Action Army. McAulay writes that the 1860 Colts “remained in cavalry service in the post-war period up to the adoption of the .45-cal. Colt Single Action Army revolver in 1873.” Rock Island adds that the designers of the new revolver drew on the 1860 Army’s grip. Read our history of the Colt Single Action Army.

Is There an 1860 Navy? The Colt 1861 Navy

Many readers search for an “1860 Navy.” The Colt they usually mean is the Model 1861 Navy, a .36 caliber gun built on the lines of the 1860 Army. The Smithsonian describes it as “manufactured from 1861 through circa 1873” and “designed much like the Colt Model 1860 but is somewhat smaller due to its smaller caliber.” The Met’s example, serial 12240, made in 1863, has a 7 1/2-inch barrel. Rock Island writes that it was “officially called the ‘New Model Navy or Belt pistol'” and counts 38,864 made, against more than 200,000 Armies.

Colt 1861 Navy in front of a Colt 1860 Army
A Colt 1861 Navy (front) and a Colt 1860 Army (back). Photo by Michael E. Cumpston, Wikimedia Commons, CC BY-SA 3.0.

The Ordnance Department bought few of them. Rock Island records a 2,000-gun contract signed on April 13, 1861, and 363 more bought from Colt’s distributors.

1851 Navy vs 1860 Army: Where the Record and the Legend Disagree

  • Why it is called the Navy. The Smithsonian says “The term ‘Navy’ refers to the caliber of the revolver, not necessarily the branch of service.” The Met says the name came from the cylinder scene: the naval and cavalry designs “became so well-known that the Holster and Belt revolvers became officially and popularly known as the Dragoon and Navy pistols, respectively.” Both explanations appear in museum records. The U.S. Navy did buy the revolver from 1852.
  • The date of the sea fight. The Met and Walke’s journal give May 16, 1843. The National Maritime Museum’s record for serial 23774 says the scene is “dated 16 March 1843.” Walke’s journal is the eyewitness record.
  • When the Navy appeared. The Met dates its serial no. 2 to 1850, and the Smithsonian counts production from 1850. Another Met record says the model was “introduced in 1851.”
  • What Colt charged. Rock Island writes that Colt charged the Union “$20 to $23” for each 1860 Army in the first half of the war. The 1862 commission report gives $25, then $14.50. McAulay gives the same two prices and a later one of $14.
  • Olmsted’s Navies. Rock Island quotes Olmsted as “There are probably in Texas about as many [Navy] revolvers as male adults.” The word in brackets is Rock Island’s. Olmsted wrote “revolvers,” and his praise is for Colt’s revolvers in general.
  • The date of the factory fire. Rock Island and our own fire article give February 4, 1864. McAulay gives the morning of February 5.
  • Robert E. Lee’s Navy. Rock Island says Lee’s engraved Colt Navy “is displayed in the American Civil War Museum in Richmond.” We found no record for the story that W. L. Ormsby presented it to him. A Robert E. Lee commemorative Colt Navy was made in 1971, “One of 4,750,” and the United States Historical Society issued another in 1984.
  • Custer and the 1860 Army. Many lists say Custer carried an 1860 Army. Our article on Custer’s guns found no wartime record that names his revolver.
  • Wild Bill Hickok. Hickok is linked with a pair of Navies. Rock Island, which has offered one at auction, warns that “Most revolvers claiming an attribution to Wild Bill Hickok can be quickly dismissed as ‘fanciful talk.'”

1851 Navy and 1860 Army Reproductions

Uberti builds both. Its 1851 Navy is .36 caliber with a 7 1/2-inch barrel and a brass backstrap and trigger guard, listed at 2.61 pounds. Its 1860 Army is .44 caliber with an 8-inch barrel, listed at 2.62 pounds. MidwayUSA carries the Uberti 1851 Navy and the Uberti 1860 Army. For loading, see our page on the percussion cap.

Uberti’s instruction manual for its black powder revolvers is the English PDF linked from both product pages (file dated October 24, 2011). It says that “Black powder is the only safe propellant for use in any muzzle loading firearm.” Uberti’s manual gives standard and maximum charges for each caliber; use the manual that came with your own revolver.

For the revolvers that came before these two, read about the Colt Paterson and Sam Colt.

Books on the Colt Navy and Army

Book links go to Amazon, and Powder & Lead earns a commission on qualifying purchases.

  • Sale! The Colt Model 1860 Army Revolver

    The Colt Model 1860 Army Revolver

    Purchase on Amazon
  • Civil War Revolvers: Myth vs. Reality

    Civil War Revolvers: Myth vs. Reality

    Purchase on Amazon
  • The Book of Colt Firearms

    The Book of Colt Firearms

    Purchase on Amazon
  • Sale! Flayderman's Guide to Antique American Firearms and Their Values

    Flayderman's Guide to Antique American Firearms and Their Values

    Purchase on Amazon
  • The Story of Colt's Revolver: The Biography of Col. Samuel Colt

    The Story of Colt’s Revolver: The Biography of Col. Samuel Colt

    Purchase on Amazon
  • Percussion Colt Revolvers

    Percussion Colt Revolvers

    Purchase on Amazon
  • Charles W. Pate, The Colt Model 1860 Army Revolver (Mowbray, 2018).
  • Peter Schiffers, Civil War Revolvers: Myth vs. Reality (Mowbray, 2013).
  • R. L. Wilson, The Book of Colt Firearms (Blue Book Publications, 2008).
  • Norm Flayderman, Flayderman’s Guide to Antique American Firearms and Their Values (9th edition, 2007).
  • William B. Edwards, The Story of Colt’s Revolver: The Biography of Col. Samuel Colt (Stackpole, 1953).
  • The Metropolitan Museum of Art, Percussion Colt Revolvers, catalogue of a 1942 loan exhibition.

Sources

  • Samuel Colt, U.S. Patent No. 7,629, “Improvement in Revolving Chambered Fire-Arms,” September 10, 1850.
  • Charles B. Richards, U.S. Patent No. 117,461, “Improvement in Revolving Fire-Arms,” July 25, 1871.
  • J. Holt and Robert Dale Owen, report of the commission on ordnance contracts to the Secretary of War, July 1, 1862, in The War of the Rebellion: Official Records of the Union and Confederate Armies, Series III, Volume 2, pp. 188 to 195 (p. 192).
  • Journal of Midshipman Alfred Walke, April and May 1843, Texas Navy Papers, Texas Navy exhibit, Texas State Library and Archives Commission.
  • Frederick Law Olmsted, A Journey Through Texas (New York, 1857), pp. 74 to 75.
  • The Metropolitan Museum of Art: Colt Model 1851 Navy, serial no. 2; Gold-inlaid Colt Model 1851 Navy, serial no. 20133; Cased Colt Model 1860 Army, serial no. 7569; Colt Model 1861 Navy, serial no. 12240; Colt Model 1851 Navy with Thuer conversion, serial no. 27060; Griswold and Gunnison revolver, serial no. 2651.
  • Smithsonian Institution, National Museum of American History: Colt Model 1851 Navy Revolver; Colt Model 1861 Navy revolver.
  • National Maritime Museum, Royal Museums Greenwich, Colt Navy 1851 Pattern, AAA2435.
  • NRA National Firearms Museum, Colt Model 1860 Army Percussion Revolver.
  • John McAulay, “Colt’s New Model Holster Pistol in the Civil War,” American Rifleman, February 21, 2013.
  • Rock Island Auction Company, “The Colt 1851 Navy: America’s Belt Revolver”, “Colt 1860 Army” (Joe Engesser, citing Pate and Flayderman), and lots 66/881 and 5031/550.
  • A. Uberti S.p.A., 1851 Navy and 1860 Army product pages, and Instruction Manual, Black Powder Revolvers (English PDF, file dated October 24, 2011).
  • Royal Society of Chemistry, Periodic Table: Lead; National Institute of Standards and Technology, Handbook 44 (2026), Appendix C.

If you know of any forums or sites that should be referenced on this listing, please let us know here.


Join the inner-circle! Sign up now for exclusive articles, offers, and discounts straight to your mail!

Email Sign-up form

Related Posts:

  • Antique revolver firearm with a wooden grip and metallic barrel, displayed on a plain background.
    Colt 1860 Army Revolver: History, Specs, and Legacy
  • Colt Walker revolver serial no. 1017, made at Whitneyville in 1847
    The Colt Walker: Once Touted as the Most Powerful…
  • High-quality bolt-action rifle with wooden stock and metal barrel, ideal for shooting sports, hunting, and precision target practice. Durable and reliable firearm from Powder & Lead collection.
    Sharps Rifles: History and Modern Reproductions…

Continue Reading

← The 1855 Colt New Model Revolving Rifle
The 1863 Starr Army Revolver: Unsung Civil War Hero →

Privacy | Terms | Join our mailing list | We support | Activities | Reloading Manuals | Returns and Refunds
As an Amazon Associate and an affiliate of other networks this site earns from qualifying purchases. Amazon and the Amazon logo are trademarks of Amazon.com, Inc, or its affiliates.
This site uses IP2Location LITE data available from https://lite.ip2location.com.
Copyright 2023 Powder & Lead